AuthorTitleCitationSummaryYearType
Angela S. Boettcher, Quentin H. Morse, Nora Rainey Olson Cooke, Erin McLaughlin, Caroline Young, Charissa Wood, Sasha Strong, Natasha Viteri, Taylor Schad INTRODUCTION TO THE SPECIAL ISSUE: A RETROSPECTIVE ON RACE IN AMERICA 92 University of Colorado Law Review 1259 (Special Issue 2021) On May 25th, 2020, George Floyd was arrested by four Minneapolis Police Officers for attempting to pass a counterfeit twenty-dollar bill. To subdue a nonviolent Mr. Floyd, Officer Derek Chauvin knelt on Mr. Floyd's neck. Despite Mr. Floyd repeatedly gasping I can't breathe and eventually losing consciousness, Officer Chauvin held him pinned for... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  IRS issues draft guidance on Native American COVID relief payments 6/9/2021 Articles FTWA (June 9, 2021)   2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  IS AN EMPLOYEE WHO EXERCISES EEO RIGHTS IN CONNECTION WITH COVID-19 PROTECTED FROM RETALIATION HR Compliance 8493920 (2021) Issue: An Asian-American employee complained to you about a coworker's abusive comments accusing Asian people of causing and spreading COVID-19. After an internal investigation was completed and appropriate action was taken, the employee's supervisor told him she didn't appreciate him going around her to HR to report the harassment. Since then,... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  Key COVID-19 Insurance Coverage Cases Tracker (US) 2021 Minnesota Senate Resolution No. 48, Minnesota First Regular Session of the Ninety-Second Legislative Session (4/12/2021) (4/20/2021) A table of key insurance coverage cases filed to recover losses related to the ongoing 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic. The table summarizes each case, identifies the insurance coverage implicated, and contains links to each complaint and related resources. The cases are listed in reverse chronological order. 2021 No Information
  Key COVID-19 Insurance Coverage Cases Tracker (US): 2020 and 2021 2021 A tracker of key insurance coverage cases to recover losses related to the ongoing 2019 novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic. The tracker lists the cases in reverse chronological order, summarizes each case, and identifies the insurance coverage and policy provisions each case implicates, including business interruption coverage, civil... 2021 Other Documents
Khiara M. Bridges LANGUAGE ON THE MOVE: "CANCEL CULTURE," "CRITICAL RACE THEORY," AND THE DIGITAL PUBLIC SPHERE 131 Yale Law Journal Forum 767 (January 26, 2022) Scores of people have been talking about cancel culture and Critical Race Theory recently. However, what people mean when they use the terms varies wildly. This Essay examines the recent drift around the meaning of these terms, analyzing the role that the digital public sphere has played in generating these examples of language on the... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Mary Louise Frampton LAW SCHOOL DESIGN FROM A CRITICAL RACE PERSPECTIVE: THE GENESIS OF THE CHARRETTE 25 U.C. Davis Social Justice Law Review 53 (Summer, 2021) Crises often enable us to see the world in a different light and to talk more honestly about painful subjects. COVID-19 has been a calamity that has sown death and despair, distrust, and division, but it has also created the opportunity for this generation of Americans to see how racial hierarchy infects everything. For those who could previously... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Samuel Vincent Jones LAW SCHOOLS, CULTURAL COMPETENCY, AND ANTI-BLACK RACISM: THE LIBERTY OF DISCRIMINATION 21 Berkeley Journal of African-American Law & Policy 84 (2021) Introduction. 84 I. Do Law Schools Have Liberty to Discriminate Against Black Law Students?. 86 A. The Black Law Student Experience. 87 B. Law Schools and the Liberty to Foster Anti-Black Racism. 90 II. Should Law Schools Require Cultural Competency Instruction as a Means to Curtail Anti-Black Racial Discrimination?. 96 A. Cultural Competency... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Celine Castronuovo Lawsuit from Stephen Miller group alleges racial discrimination in distribution of COVID-19 relief The Hill (May 13, 2021) A legal group founded by ex-Trump aide Stephen Miller on Thursday filed another lawsuit accusing the Biden administration of racial discrimination in the distribution of COVID-19 relief funds, this time for money designated for restaurant owners. 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Catherine J.K. Sandoval , Patricia A. Cain , Stephen F. Diamond , Allen S. Hammond , Jean C. Love , Stephen E. Smith , Solmaz Nabipour, M.D. LEGAL EDUCATION DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC: PUT HEALTH, SAFETY AND EQUITY FIRST 61 Santa Clara Law Review 367 (2021) The COVID-19 viral pandemic exposed equity and safety culture gaps in American legal education. Legal education forms part of America's Critical Infrastructure whose continuity is important to the economy, public safety, democracy, and the national security of the United States. To address the COVID-19 pandemic and prepare for future viral... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Mirko Bagaric , Peter Isham , Jennifer Svilar , Theo Alexander LESS PRISON TIME MATTERS: A ROADMAP TO REDUCING THE DISCRIMINATORY IMPACT OF THE SENTENCING SYSTEM AGAINST AFRICAN AMERICANS AND INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIANS 37 Georgia State University Law Review 1405 (Summer, 2021) The criminal justice system discriminates against African Americans. There are a number of stages of the criminal justice process. Sentencing is the sharp end of the system because this is where the community acts in its most coercive manner by intentionally inflecting hardships on offenders. African Americans comprise approximately 40% of the... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Amanda Harris , Brittíni “Ree Belle” Gray , Ciearra Walker , Melinique Walls Castellanos LESSONS LEARNED FROM COMMUNITY-DRIVEN RESPONSIVENESS DURING COVID-19 14 Saint Louis University Journal of Health Law & Policy 429 (2021) People of color are suffering and dying from COVID-19 at greater rates than the general population. Additionally, population-level health interventions can worsen health disparities by failing to reach already underserved populations. In response, PrepareSTL, a collaborative, community-led campaign, aims to reach communities of color in St. Louis... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Yong-Shik Lee MANAGING COVID-19: LEGAL AND INSTITUTIONAL ISSUES 23 Minnesota Journal of Law, Science & Technology 1 (November 11, 2021) The spread of the recent pandemic, COVID-19--which began in Wuhan, in December of 2019--has created an unprecedented impact on public health in the United States and across the world. As of October 2021, the United States reported over 44 million infection cases and over 720,000 deaths. Those cases represent over 18 percent of the reported... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
John Bowden Mazie Hirono: Asian American, Pacific Islander community 'feels under siege' amid rise in hate crimes No Citation Available, The Hill (4/19/2021); (Publication Name: The Hill) (4/19/2021) Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-Hawaii) said Monday that the Asian American and Pacific Islander community feels as if it is under siege" in the U.S. amid a rise in anti-Asian discrimination and violence." 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  Memorandum Condemning and Combating Racism, Xenophobia, and Intolerance Against Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders in the United States White House (1/26/2021) Search Snippet: ...The White House Office of Communications MEMORANDUM CONDEMNING AND COMBATING RACISM, XENOPHOBIA, AND INTOLERANCE AGAINST ASIAN AMERICANS AND PACIFIC ISLANDERS IN THE UNITED STATES January 26, 2021 Advancing inclusion and... 2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  Memorandum Condemning and Combating Racism, Xenophobia, and Intolerance Against Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders in the United States (1/26/2021) (White House) (1/26/2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  Memorandum to Board: Racial and Ethnic Diversity on the Board 2021 A form of memorandum to be delivered to a public company's board of directors highlighting key issues and recent developments to consider when evaluating racial and ethnic board diversity and related disclosure. 2021 Other Documents
Natalie Netzel, Ana Pottratz Acosta, Joanna Woolman, Katherine Kruse, Jonathan Geffen MITCHELL HAMLINE SCHOOL OF LAW SUMMER 2020 COVID-19 LEGAL RESPONSE CLINIC 28 Clinical Law Review 301 (Fall, 2021) This essay is a reflection on lawyering in a time of crisis. It details the Mitchell Hamline School of Law Clinical Faculty's response to the community needs resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic by creating the COVID-19 Legal Response Clinic. It also recounts the impact of the murder of George Floyd and the long overdue national reckoning with... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  MORGAN RODMAN NAMED EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF WHITE HOUSE COUNCIL ON NATIVE AMERICAN AFFAIRS (May 27, 2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  National Security Directive on United States Global Leadership to Strengthen the International Covid-19 Response and to Advance Global Health Security and Biological Preparedness White House (1/21/2021) Search Snippet: ...DIRECTIVE ON UNITED STATES GLOBAL LEADERSHIP TO STRENGTHEN THE INTERNATIONAL COVID- 19 RESPONSE AND TO ADVANCE GLOBAL HEALTH SECURITY AND BIOLOGICAL PREPAREDNESS... 2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  National Security Directive on United States Global Leadership to Strengthen the International Covid-19 Response and to Advance Global Health Security and Biological Preparedness (1/21/2021) (White House) (1/21/2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  NEW BLOG POST BY DEPUTY SECRETARY WALLY ADEYEMO ON CENTERING AMERICAN RESCUE PLAN IMPLEMENTATION ON RACIAL EQUITY Treas. JY-0363 (September 17, 2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  NEW EEOC GUIDANCE: YOUR EMPLOYEES CAN SUE YOU FOR COVID-19 RETALIATION (IF IT'S BASED ON A PROTECTED CLASSIFICATION) - EXPERT GUIDANCE HR Compliance 5907988 (2021) The latest series of Covid-19 news is discomfiting. The Biden administration is fighting in court for its vaccinate-or-test mandate. Europe, Asia, and parts of the U.S. are suffering from a heavy uptick in Delta variant Covid-19 illnesses that are starting to look as bad as late 2020-most gravely among the unvaccinated. And we continue to burn... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Breonne DeDecker, Davida Finger, Shana M. Griffin NEW ORLEANS EVICTIONS DURING COVID-19 (2020) 30 Journal of Affordable Housing & Community Development Law 227 (2021) I. Introduction. 227 II. History of the Challenge. 231 III. Current Housing Inequities. 235 A. Evictions Filed in New Orleans During the 2020 Moratoria. 237 B. Insights From Eviction Court Monitoring. 239 C. Eviction Cases by Race. 247 IV. Implications for Further Study. 249 V. Conclusion. 251 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  NEW YORK STATE DIVISION OF HUMAN RIGHTS, CORONAVIRUS REPONSES RELATED CHANGES & UPDATES 20210517P City Bar Center for Continuing Legal Education 1 (May 17, 2021) May 6, 2021 | 11:08 am COVID-19 is still spreading, even as the vaccine is here. Wear a mask, social distance and stay up to date on New York State's vaccination program. GET THE FACTS > New York State Division of Human Rights Office Operations Discrimination Relating to the Coronavirus Under the New York State Human Rights Law Temporary... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Nina A. Kohn NURSING HOMES, COVID-19, AND THE CONSEQUENCES OF REGULATORY FAILURE 110 Geo. L.J. Online 1, Georgetown Law Journal Online (Spring, 2021); (Publication Name: Georgetown Law Journal Online) (Spring, 2021) This essay explores the COVID-19 crisis in America's nursing homes and its lessons for the future of long-term care. It challenges narratives portraying nursing homes as the unfortunate victims of COVID-19 by showing how the crisis is the foreseeable result of regulatory gaps and failures that have long enabled nursing homes to engage in systemic... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
James T. Smith NURTURING THE BABY BOND PROPOSAL: HOW TAX PRINCIPLES CAN CLOSE THE RACIAL WEALTH GAP IN THE UNITED STATES 94 Temple Law Review 147 (Fall, 2021) [T]he problems of racial injustice and economic injustice cannot be solved without a radical redistribution of political and economic power. Every day I'm trying to play catch-up, said Kourtney McGowan--a Black mother from California who became unemployed after her company refused to accommodate her work schedule during the COVID-19 pandemic.... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  OAR 333-018-0011 RACE, ETHNICITY, LANGUAGE AND DISABILITY COVID-19 DATA REPORTING (LAST EDITED NOVEMBER 23, 2021) State Healthcare Laws Library 333-018-0011 (2021) (1) The reporting requirements in this rule are in addition to the information required to be reported under OAR 333-018-0010. (2) For purposes of this rule: (a) Congregate setting means an environment where a number of people reside, meet or gather in close proximity for either a limited or extended period of time, and include but are not... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Cindy A. Schipani , Terry Morehead Dworkin , Devin Abney OVERCOMING GENDER DISCRIMINATION IN BUSINESS: RECONSIDERING MENTORING IN THE POST #ME-TOO AND COVID-19 ERAS 23 University of Pennsylvania Journal of Business Law 1072 (2021) I. Origins of Female Mentorship: How Female Mentorship Countered Historical Systems Of Patriarchal Inequality in the United States. 1074 II. The Perception of Women in the Workplace. 1081 III. The Post-#MeToo Era Divide. 1086 IV. The Benefits of Women Mentoring Men. 1090 V. The COVID-19 Crisis: Challenges and Opportunities. 1098 VI. Conclusion.... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Shigenori Matsui PANDEMIC: COVID-19 AND THE PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY 38 Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law 139 (2021) C1-3Table of Contents I. Introduction. 140 II. The New Coronavirus and Japan. 142 A. The New Coronavirus and Its Outbreak. 142 B. COVID-19 and Japan. 146 III. Contagious Disease Prevention System. 151 A. Infectious Disease Prevention Act. 151 IV. Immigration Control and Quarantine System. 156 A. Immigration Control System. 156 B. Quarantine System.... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Shigenori Matsui PANDEMIC: COVID-19 AND THE PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY 38 Ariz. J. Int'l & Comp. L. 139, Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law (2021); (Publication Name: Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law) (Spring, 2021) C1-3Table of Contents I. Introduction. 140 II. The New Coronavirus and Japan. 142 A. The New Coronavirus and Its Outbreak. 142 B. COVID-19 and Japan. 146 III. Contagious Disease Prevention System. 151 A. Infectious Disease Prevention Act. 151 IV. Immigration Control and Quarantine System. 156 A. Immigration Control System. 156 B. Quarantine System.... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Marika Dias PARADOX AND POSSIBILITY: MOVEMENT LAWYERING DURING THE COVID-19 HOUSING CRISIS 24 CUNY Law Review 173 (Summer, 2021) Introduction. 173 I. The Housing Movement Rising. 177 II. Really? You Want to Evict People During a Pandemic? Keeping the Eviction Mills Closed. 182 III. Cancel Rent--A Time for Bold Demands. 191 IV. Not One Cent on the Rent: A Mass Rent Strike. 200 V. Closing out--Building our power to Fight and Win. 207 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Najarian Peters PARALLEL PANDEMICS: THE AMERICAN PROBLEM OF ANTI-ENFORCEMENT, RATIONAL DISTRUST, AND COVID-19 52 Seton Hall Law Review 371 (2021) There is nothing new under the sun, but there are new suns. -Octavia E. Butler In the United States of America, we have had moments when we seemed to know what our ailments were, and we named some of them accurately and honestly. Some of our laws once sought to remedy the rot at the branch and at the root, beginning with the Civil War Amendments... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Zoë Haggerty PATENTABILITY OF COVID-19 VACCINES 2021 Boston College Intellectual Property & Technology Forum 1 (August 23, 2021) In many ways, the COVID-19 crisis has disproportionately affected the most vulnerable and underprivileged members of society. National lockdowns, halted economies, and overburdened hospital systems have significantly exacerbated the obstacles faced by those already financially insecure. In light of these unique and widespread challenges,... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Jeffrey H. Brochin, J.D. Pharmaceutical News: States Are Diverging from Cdc Guidance on Covid-19 Vaccination Priorities Wolters Kluwer Health Law Daily (1/13/2021) Access to Covid-19 vaccines during the first three months of the roll-out may depend to a great deal on geography. States are developing their own COVID-19 vaccine distribution policies, unique from CDC guidance and from each other, resulting in a vaccine roll-out labyrinth across the country, according to a Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) study on...; Search Snippet: ...Story PHARMACEUTICAL NEWS: STATES ARE DIVERGING FROM CDC GUIDANCE ON COVID- 19 VACCINATION PRIORITIES January 13, 2021 By Jeffrey H. Brochin, J.D... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Jeffrey H. Brochin, J.D. Pharmaceutical News: States Are Diverging from Cdc Guidance on Covid-19 Vaccination Priorities Wolters Kluwer Health Law Daily(1/13/2021) (1/13/2021) Access to Covid-19 vaccines during the first three months of the roll-out may depend to a great deal on geography. States are developing their own COVID-19 vaccine distribution policies, unique from CDC guidance and from each other, resulting in a vaccine roll-out labyrinth across the country, according to a Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) study on... 2021 Law Reviews and Other Secondary Sources
Manaire T. Vaughn PRACTICING WITH GRACE 78-APR Bench & B. Minn. 26, Bench and Bar of Minnesota (April, 2021); (Publication Name: Bench and Bar of Minnesota) (April, 2021) To truly understand the impact of the coronavirus pandemic, we must look at all covid-related legal issues with a systemic lens and be open to creative problem solving. It's hard to think of an area in which this is more emphatically true than with respect to the impending tsunami of eviction filings once federal and local moratoria are rescinded.... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Benjamin P. Cooper PRELIMINARY THOUGHTS ON ACCESS TO JUSTICE IN THE AGE OF COVID-19 56 Gonzaga Law Review 227 (2020/2021) C1-3Table of contents L1-2Introduction . L3227 I. The Justice Gap. 228 II. The Impact of the Coronavirus on the Justice Gap. 232 A. The Bad News. 232 B. Silver Linings. 234 C. Remaining Obstacles and Challenges. 238 L1-2Conclusion . L3241 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  PRESIDENT BIDEN ANNOUNCES INTENT TO APPOINT COMMISSIONERS TO THE PRESIDENT'S ADVISORY COMMISSION ON ASIAN AMERICANS, NATIVE HAWAIIANS, AND PACIFIC ISLANDERS (December 20, 2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  PRESS BRIEFING BY WHITE HOUSE COVID-19 RESPONSE TEAM AND PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICIALS (October 20, 2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  PRESS BRIEFING BY WHITE HOUSE COVID-19 RESPONSE TEAM AND PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICIALS (September 28, 2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
  PRESS BRIEFING BY WHITE HOUSE COVID-19 RESPONSE TEAM AND PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICIALS No Citation Available (4/14/2021) (4/12/2021)   2021 Administrative Decisions & Guidance
Mary Crossley PRISONS, NURSING HOMES, AND MEDICAID: A COVID-19 CASE STUDY IN HEALTH INJUSTICE 30 Annals of Health Law and Life Sciences 101 (Summer, 2021) As the coronavirus closed down the United States economy in March 2020, it did not take long for predictions to emerge claiming that COVID-19 would disproportionately affect Black communities. Only weeks into the shutdown, Dr. Uché Blackstock, a health equity expert, began sounding the alarm, stating in an interview [w]hen it hits the fan, we're... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
R. Chantz Richens PRIVACY IN A PANDEMIC: AN EXAMINATION OF THE UNITED STATES' RESPONSE TO COVID-19 ANALYZING PRIVACY RIGHTS AFFORDED TO CHILDREN UNDER INTERNATIONAL LAW 28 Willamette Journal of International Law and Dispute Resolution 244 (2021) Among legal disciplines and focus areas that have emerged and evolved in the twenty-first century, the concept of child law has been at the forefront. An examination of the historical, psychological, sociological, and political insights into childhood show the metaphorical explosion of research devoted to understanding children and childhood within... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
L. S. Tellier Proof as to exclusion of or discrimination against eligible class or race in respect to jury in criminal case 1 American Law Reports ALR2d 1291 (The ALR databases are made current by the weekly addition of relevant new cases.) It is recognized that an intentional, planned, and deliberate exclusion of, or discrimination against, members of a particular political or economic group, religious faith, race, or sex, by officers in charge of the selection and summoning of jurors, is in contravention of the constitutional right to jury trial and of the due process" and "equal..." 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Chesa Boudin PROSECUTORS, POWER, AND JUSTICE: BUILDING AN ANTI-RACIST PROSECUTORIAL SYSTEM 73 Rutgers University Law Review 1325 (Summer, 2021) Well thank you for that really warm introduction. Good afternoon, everyone--I guess it's afternoon, whichever time zone we're all in. I'm really pleased to be here, not physically here, but here with you at the Rutgers University Law Review Symposium. It's always a pleasure to speak alongside, and to work in partnership with, my colleague across... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Katie Raitz PUBLIC HEALTH AND RACIAL INEQUALITY: WHY THE OPPORTUNITY ZONE PROGRAM FAILS LOW-INCOME COMMUNITIES AND COSTS LIVES 12 UC Irvine Law Review 315 (November, 2021) The rich man's dog gets more in the way of vaccination, medicine and medical care than do the workers upon whom the rich man's wealth is built. Poor health outcomes are linked to long-standing wealth disparities for people of color in the United States. Wealth inequality has gotten worse over the past decades, despite attempts to improve it. The... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Lynnise E. Phillips Pantin RACE AND EQUITY IN THE AGE OF UNICORNS 72 Hastings Law Journal 1453 (May, 2021) This Article critically examines startup culture and its legal predicates. The Article analyzes innovation culture as a whole and uses the downfall of Theranos to illustrate the deficiencies in Silicon Valley culture, centering on race and class. The Article demonstrates that the rise and fall of the unicorn startup Theranos and its founder,... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
  RACE AND ETHNICITY DATA FOR MEDICAID BENEFICIARIES - DECEMBER 2021 Health Care Compliance Reporter 6278736 (2021) Complete and consistent race and ethnicity data for Medicaid beneficiaries are critical to identifying and addressing health disparities. As the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted disparities among racial and ethnic groups, the availability and quality of data on race and ethnicity warrants a closer look in order to accurately and appropriately... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
Craig Konnoth RACE AND MEDICAL DOUBLE-BINDS 121 Columbia Law Review Forum 135 (October 8, 2021) Race and medicine scholarship is beset by a conundrum. On one hand, some racial justice scholars and advocates frame the harms that racial minorities experience through a medical lens. Poverty and homelessness are social determinants of health that medical frameworks should account for. Racism itself is a public health threat. On the other hand,... 2021 Law Review Articles and Other Secondary Sources
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21