AuthorTitleCitationSummaryYear
Bruce A. Green , Brandon P. Ruben SHOULD VICTIMS' VIEWS INFLUENCE PROSECUTORS' DECISIONS? 87 Brooklyn Law Review 1127 (Summer, 2022) When prosecutors make discretionary decisions in criminal cases, how should they take account of individual victims' views of the fair and just outcome? No doubt, many crime victims have views, including about whether the person who harmed them should be prosecuted, diverted from the criminal process, or entirely left alone. But little is written... 2022
Brian Owsley SUPPLY AND DEMAND IN THE ILLEGAL EMPLOYMENT OF UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS 71 Catholic University Law Review 227 (Spring, 2022) The United States is in a quandary regarding immigration. There are over eleven million undocumented aliens residing in the country with about eight million of them working in the American economy. The federal government has criminalized the illegal entry and the illegal reentry into the United States. Moreover, it has enacted a statute making it... 2022
Rashida Richardson, Amba Kak SUSPECT DEVELOPMENT SYSTEMS: DATABASING MARGINALITY AND ENFORCING DISCIPLINE 55 University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform 813 (Summer, 2022) Algorithmic accountability law--focused on the regulation of data-driven systems like artificial intelligence (AI) or automated decision-making (ADM) tools--is the subject of lively policy debates, heated advocacy, and mainstream media attention. Concerns have moved beyond data protection and individual due process to encompass a broader range of... 2022
Kevin R. Johnson SYSTEMIC RACISM IN THE U.S. IMMIGRATION LAWS 97 Indiana Law Journal 1455 (Spring, 2022) This Essay analyzes how aggressive activism in a California mountain town at the tail end of the nineteenth century commenced a chain reaction resulting in state and ultimately national anti-Chinese immigration laws. The constitutional immunity through which the Supreme Court upheld those laws deeply affected the future trajectory of U.S.... 2022
Sarah Brady Siff TARGETED MARIJUANA LAW ENFORCEMENT IN LOS ANGELES, 1914-1959 49 Fordham Urban Law Journal 643 (March, 2022) Introduction. 643 I. Anti-Mexican Aims of the First Marijuana Ban. 644 II. Marijuana Was a Whole Different Thing Back Then. 648 III. From Bad to Worse: Racialized Enforcement and New Policing Strategies. 654 IV. Cultural Conquest: Targeting the Hip and Famous. 658 V. Escalation of Unconstitutional Enforcement. 667 Conclusion: Confronting the Legacy... 2022
Barbara Fedders THE ANTI-PARENT JUVENILE COURT 69 UCLA Law Review 746 (May, 2022) This Article identifies and analyzes features of the juvenile delinquency court that harm the people on whom children most heavily depend: their parents. By negatively affecting a child's family--creating financial stress, undermining a parent's central role in rearing her child, and damaging the parent-child bond--these parent-harming features... 2022
Alexis Hoag THE COLOR OF JUSTICE 120 Michigan Law Review 977 (April, 2022) Free Justice: a History of the Public Defender in Twentieth Century America. By Sara Mayeux. University of North Carolina Press. 2020. Pp. xi, 271. $26.95. Writing about history requires making certain decisions: when to start the account, what to include and exclude, which documents and artifacts to rely upon, and what questions to address. One... 2022
Tom I. Romero, II THE COLOR OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT: OBSERVATIONS OF A BROWN BUFFALO ON RACIAL IMPACT STATEMENTS IN THE MOVEMENT FOR WATER JUSTICE 25 CUNY Law Review 241 (Summer, 2022) This Article advocates for the adoption of racial impact statements (RIS) in local government decision making, particularly among water utilities. Situated in the larger history of water and climate injustice in Colorado and the arid American West, this Article examines ways that racially minoritized communities engage and contest legal and... 2022
Thomas Ward Frampton THE DANGEROUS FEW: TAKING SERIOUSLY PRISON ABOLITION AND ITS SKEPTICS 135 Harvard Law Review 2013 (June, 2022) Prison abolition, in the span of just a few short years, has established a foothold in elite criminal legal discourse. But the basic question of how abolitionists would address the dangerous few often receives superficial treatment; the problem constitutes a spectral force haunting abolitionist thought . as soon as abolitionist discourses... 2022
Khiara M. Bridges THE DYSGENIC STATE: ENVIRONMENTAL INJUSTICE AND DISABILITY-SELECTIVE ABORTION BANS 110 California Law Review 297 (April, 2022) Disability-selective abortion bans are laws that prohibit individuals from terminating a pregnancy because the fetus has been diagnosed with a health impairment. Many environmental toxins--to which low-income people and people of color disproportionately are exposed--are known to cause impairments in fetuses. When the fact of environmental... 2022
Gabriel J. Chin *, Anna Ratner ** THE END OF CALIFORNIA'S ANTI-ASIAN ALIEN LAND LAW: A CASE STUDY IN REPARATIONS AND TRANSITIONAL JUSTICE 29 Asian American Law Journal 17 (2022) For nearly a century, California law embodied a rabid anti-Asian policy, which included school segregation, discriminatory law enforcement, a prohibition on marriage with Whites, denial of voting rights, and imposition of many other hardships. The Alien Land Law was a California innovation, copied in over a dozen other states. The Alien Land Law,... 2022
Brendan Williams THE EXPENDABLES: HISPANIC WORKERS IN THE U.S. DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC 13 Alabama Civil Rights & Civil Liberties Law Review 119 (2021-2022) I. Essential Work. 121 II. Health Care Inequities. 127 III. White Privilege and Opposition to COVID-19 Safeguards. 136 IV. Conclusion. 141 2022
Mary D. Fan THE HIDDEN HARMS OF PRIVACY PENALTIES 56 U.C. Davis Law Review 71 (November, 2022) How to frame privacy penalties to protect our personal information is an important question as demands for legislation and proposals proliferate. The predominant assumption in calls for a comprehensive consumer privacy regime is that regulation and penalties arm the consumer David against Goliath businesses. Missing in the focus on powerful... 2022
Tina S. Ching THE HISTORY OF OREGON'S SO-CALLED "SANCTUARY" LAW 114 Law Library Journal 233 (2022) Sanctuary laws are known as intensely partisan policy responding to immigration decisions made during the Trump administration. However, Oregon's law has been in place since 1987 and continues to evolve. This article documents the history of this pioneering state law through the passage of the 2021 Sanctuary Promise Act. Introduction. 233... 2022
Nikolas Bowie , Norah Rast THE IMAGINARY IMMIGRATION CLAUSE 120 Michigan Law Review 1419 (May, 2022) For the past century, the Supreme Court has skeptically scrutinized Congress's power to enact healthcare laws and other domestic legislation, insisting that nothing in the Constitution gives Congress a general power to regulate an individual from cradle to grave. Yet when Congress regulates immigrants, the Court has contradictorily assumed that... 2022
Aysha A. Chowdhry THE IMMIGRATION & NATIONAL SECURITY NEXUS: BALANCING SECURITY, OPENNESS, AND HUMANITY 36 Georgetown Immigration Law Journal 1041 (Spring, 2022) Immigration to the United States stretches back hundreds of years, and a review of its arc shows that at different points in history, the flow of people to its shores has been managed--and manipulated--in different ways. Analyzing the National Security Strategies (NSS) of three successive modern administrations will show that contemporary American... 2022
Taleed El-Sabawi, Jennifer Oliva THE INFLUENCE OF WHITE EXCEPTIONALISM ON DRUG WAR DISCOURSE 94 Temple Law Review 649 (Summer, 2022) For much of its history, the United States has adopted a punitive approach to escalating overdose rates and addiction through the prohibition or stringent regulation of drugs deemed dangerous or habit forming. The policy tools used to support this approach rely on criminal punishment for the possession and sale of such substances and are based on... 2022
Asli Ü. Bâli THE LIMITS OF PRODEMOCRATIC INTERNATIONAL LAW IN EUROPE 23 Chicago Journal of International Law 45 (Summer, 2022) Tom Ginsburg's Democracies and International Law explores the ways in which regional human rights regimes have been designed to promote and protect democracy and the degree of their success in an age of democratic backsliding. In this symposium contribution, I examine the impact of the relationship between the European Union (E.U.) and Turkey on... 2022
Anneke Dunbar-Gronke THE MANDATE FOR CRITICAL RACE THEORY IN THIS TIME 69 UCLA Law Review Discourse 4 (2022) A necessary conclusion from Critical Race Theory (CRT) is that Black people cannot look to the law for justice because racism is baked into the law. As a result, the movement for Black liberation cannot rely on the law for just outcomes. This result does not, however, mean that we have to abandon legal interventions altogether. Instead, for those... 2022
Rebecca Brown THE NEW "SANCTUARY STATE": UNITED STATES v. CALIFORNIA AND LESSONS FOR COMPREHENSIVE IMMIGRATION REFORM 55 Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review 185 (Winter, 2022) The Trump Administration waged war on so-called sanctuary policies. The Administration targeted localities and states that refused to subscribe to the Administration's enforcement goals. The battle was most potent in the fight with California, culminating in the federal case United States v. California over California's recently enacted... 2022
Sophia DenUyl THE PARTICULAR HARMS OF THE "GOOD IMMIGRANT" versus "BAD IMMIGRANT" CONSTRUCTION ON BLACK IMMIGRANTS IN THE UNITED STATES 36 Georgetown Immigration Law Journal 755 (Winter, 2022) In the fall of 2021, video and images surfaced of Border Patrol agents on horseback corralling and whipping Haitian migrants with their reins along the U.S.-Mexico border in Del Rio, Texas. These migrants were being rounded up for deportation under Title 42, a Trump-era provision invoked during the COVID-19 pandemic under the guise of public... 2022
Dalia Castillo-Granados , Rachel Leya Davidson , Laila L. Hlass , Rebecca Scholtz THE RACIAL JUSTICE IMPERATIVE TO REIMAGINE IMMIGRANT CHILDREN'S RIGHTS: SPECIAL IMMIGRANT JUVENILES AS A CASE STUDY 71 American University Law Review 1779 (June, 2022) The immigration legal system has codified and perpetuated racial violence in many ways, yet the experiences of young people of color in this system have yet to be deeply examined. This Article surfaces the distinct and varied racialized harms that children experience in the immigration system through the example of Special Immigrant Juveniles.... 2022
Mariana Olaizola Rosenblat THE ROLE OF TRANSNATIONAL CIVIL SOCIETY IN SHAPING INTERNATIONAL VALUES, POLICIES, AND LAW 23 Chicago Journal of International Law 144 (Summer, 2022) This Essay suggests that predictions about the character of international law in the context of rising authoritarianism may be nuanced by paying closer attention to the influence of transnational civil society (TCS) on global affairs and normative development. While acknowledging that pro-liberal civil society has faced escalating threats from... 2022
Raquel Muñiz , Maria Lewis , Grace Cavanaugh , Melissa Woolsey THE SOCIAL CONTEXT OF THE LAW: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF RELIANCE INTERESTS IN THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY v. REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA 95 Southern California Law Review 857 (April, 2022) In 2020, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on the Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of the University of California case. The case concerned the rescission of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) policy, an issue that sparked the interest of a wide range of amicus curiae, including those in support of the policy. Using Critical... 2022
Asees Bhasin THE TELEHEALTH "REVOLUTION" & HOW IT FAILS TO TRANSFORM CARE FOR UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS 24 North Carolina Journal of Law & Technology 1 (October, 2022) The outbreak of COVID-19 led to the rapid adoption and expansion of telehealth services. Upon understanding telehealth's potential to reach under served populations, people began referring to this method of health care delivery as revolutionary. This reputation stuck, even though it quickly became obvious that telehealth utilization was more... 2022
David K. Hausman THE UNEXAMINED LAW OF DEPORTATION 110 Georgetown Law Journal 973 (May, 2022) Prioritization by criminality, in which noncitizens who have been convicted of serious crimes are deported ahead of those with little or no criminal history, is the most consequential principle governing who is deported from the interior of the United States. This Article argues that, intuitive as prioritization by criminality may appear, it is... 2022
Gabriel J. Chin , Sam Chew Chin THE WAR AGAINST ASIAN SAILORS AND FISHERS 69 UCLA Law Review 572 (April, 2022) Beginning in the 1880s, maritime unions sought federal legislation to prevent Chinese, Japanese, Filipino, and Asian Indian sailors from serving as crew members on U.S.-flag vessels. The campaign succeeded and mandatory citizenship requirements for crews remain in the U.S. Code to this day. Similarly, federal and state laws limited the ability of... 2022
Kevin Johnson , Raquel Aldana , José Padilla, Amagda Pérez, Thomas Saenz , Opening Remarks, Moderator, Panelists TRANSCRIPT: THE CIVIL RIGHTS LEGACY OF JUSTICE CRUZ REYNOSO 26 U.C. Davis Social Justice Law Review 132 (Winter, 2022) The family of Justice Cruz Reynoso released the following announcement upon his death in May 2021: On May 7, 2021, former California Supreme Court Associate Justice, law professor, and civil rights activist Cruz Reynoso passed away at age 90, surrounded by his family. Reynoso was born on May 2, 1931, in Brea, California, to Francisca Ramirez... 2022
Michael Vitiello TRUMP'S LEGACY: THE LONG-TERM RISKS TO AMERICAN DEMOCRACY 26 Lewis & Clark Law Review 467 (2022) While President Trump was extreme in his contempt for legal and political norms, his presidency was consistent with the direction in which the Republican Party has moved over the past several decades. Strategies put in place by Trump and other Republicans, along with institutional aspects of our country's democracy, assure the Republican Party's... 2022
Sandra J. Chen, Samuel S.-H. Wang, Bernard Grofman, Richard F. Ober, Jr., Kyle T. Barnes, Jonathan R. Cervas TURNING COMMUNITIES OF INTEREST INTO A RIGOROUS STANDARD FOR FAIR DISTRICTING 18 Stanford Journal of Civil Rights & Civil Liberties 101 (February, 2022) Recent technological advances make possible a practical, rigorous application of communities of interest (COIs) to redisricting measures. Geographers, political scientists, and legal scholars have suggested that keeping communities together can enhance representational fairness. As other paths for redressing gerrymandering have closed in recent... 2022
Sarah H. Lorr UNACCOMMODATED: HOW THE ADA FAILS PARENTS 110 California Law Review 1315 (August, 2022) In 1990, Congress passed the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to provide a clear and comprehensive national mandate for the elimination of discrimination against individuals with disabilities. Thirty years after this landmark law, discrimination and ingrained prejudices against individuals with intellectual disabilities--especially poor... 2022
Jamie Rowen, Scott Blinder, Rebecca Hamlin , Department of Legal Studies and Political Science, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts, USA VICTIM, PERPETRATOR, NEITHER: ATTITUDES ON DESERVINGNESS AND CULPABILITY IN IMMIGRATION LAW 56 Law and Society Review 369 (September, 2022) This study examines whether there is popular support for a restrictive immigration policy aimed at denying safe haven to human rights abusers and those affiliated with terrorism. We designed a public opinion survey experiment that asks respondents to evaluate whether low level or high-level Taliban members who otherwise qualify for refugee status... 2022
Liz Bradley , Hillary Farber VIRTUALLY INCREDIBLE: RETHINKING DEFERENCE TO DEMEANOR WHEN ASSESSING CREDIBILITY IN ASYLUM CASES CONDUCTED BY VIDEO TELECONFERENCE 36 Georgetown Immigration Law Journal 515 (Winter, 2022) The COVID-19 pandemic forced courthouses around the country to shutter their doors to in-person hearings and embrace video teleconferencing (VTC), launching a technology proliferation within the U.S. legal system. Immigration courts have long been authorized to use VTC, but the pandemic prompted the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) to... 2022
Erin Griffard WEAKENING THE DEPORTATION PIPELINE BY ENCOURAGING LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES TO TERMINATE THEIR 287(G) AGREEMENTS: LOCAL STRATEGIES GROUNDED IN ADMINISTRATIVE AND MORAL IMPLICATIONS 36 Georgetown Immigration Law Journal 1087 (Spring, 2022) C1-3Table of Contents I. Introduction. 1088 II. Background on the 287(g) Program. 1089 A. Nuts and Bolts of 287(g) Agreements. 1089 B. Historical Background on 287(g) Agreements. 1093 1. 287(g) Agreements under the Trump Administration. 1094 2. 287(g) Agreements in the Biden Era. 1095 III. 287(g) Agreements Are Inherently Unjust, Ineffective, and... 2022
Amanda Frost "BY ACCIDENT OF BIRTH": THE BATTLE OVER BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP AFTER UNITED STATES v. WONG KIM ARK 32 Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities 38 (Summer, 2021) In theory, birthright citizenship has been well established in U.S. law since 1898, when the Supreme Court held in United States v. Wong Kim Ark that all born on U.S. soil are U.S. citizens. The experience of immigrants and their families over the last 120 years tells a different story, however. This article draws on government records documenting... 2021
Vincent Becraft "YEARNING TO BREATHE FREE": IMMIGRANT DUE PROCESS RIGHTS CONSTRAINED BY THE SUPREME COURT'S RECENT UPHOLDING OF 8 U.S.C. § 1226 30-SPG Kansas Journal of Law & Public Policy 281 (Spring, 2021) Most fathers envision walking their daughters down the aisle and giving a heartfelt wedding speech, toasting the new couple and reflecting, maybe bittersweetly, on the new family and life she is creating with her spouse. Juan Lozano Magdaleno's role in his daughter's wedding was reduced to giving a speech, played over speaker phone at the wedding... 2021
Carrie L. Rosenbaum (UN)EQUAL IMMIGRATION PROTECTION 50 Southwestern Law Review 231 (2021) L1-3Table of Contents I. Introduction. 231 II. Equal Protection Intent Doctrine. 236 III. Immigration UnEqual Protection. 243 A. Equal Protection Challenges to Alienage Laws. 245 B. Equal Protection Challenges to Racially Discriminatory Immigration Laws. 246 IV. DHS v. Regents - Intentional Blindness Redoubled. 253 V. Conclusion. 260 2021
Ediberto Román , Ernesto Sagás A DOMESTIC REIGN OF TERROR: DONALD TRUMP'S FAMILY SEPARATION POLICY 24 Harvard Latinx Law Review 65 (Spring, 2021) Family separation has the dubious distinction of being the most odious measure amongst Donald Trump's draconian anti-immigrant immigration policies. The policy was introduced by the Trump administration as a way to broadly deter would-be immigrants and asylum seekers by instilling in them the fear of being separated from their children. After its... 2021
Dominique Marangoni-Simonsen A FORGOTTEN HISTORY: HOW THE ASIAN AMERICAN WORKFORCE CULTIVATED MONTEREY COUNTY'S AGRICULTURAL INDUSTRY, DESPITE NATIONAL ANTI-ASIAN RHETORIC 27 Hastings Environmental Law Journal 229 (Winter, 2021) This paper analyzes the implementation of exclusionary citizenship laws against Chinese and Japanese immigrants from 1880 to 1940. It further analyzes the application of these exclusionary mechanisms to the Asian immigrant populations in Monterey County, California. It identifies how the agricultural industry in Monterey County by-passed these... 2021
Taleed El-Sabawi , Jennifer J. Carrolla A MODEL FOR DEFUNDING: AN EVIDENCE-BASED STATUTE FOR BEHAVIORAL HEALTH CRISIS RESPONSE 94 Temple Law Review 1 (Fall, 2021) Too many Black persons and other persons of color are dying at the hands of law enforcement, leading many to call for the defunding of police. These deaths were directly caused by excessive use of force by police officers but were also driven by upstream and institutional factors that include structural racism, institutional bias, and a historic... 2021
Medha D. Makhlouf , Patrick J. Glen A PATHWAY TO HEALTH CARE CITIZENSHIP FOR DACA BENEFICIARIES 12 California Law Review Online 29 (June, 2021) Since 2012, beneficiaries of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) have enjoyed a certain normalization, however tenuous, of their status in the United States: they can legally work, their removal proceedings are deferred, and they cease to accrue unlawful presence. Regarding subsidized health coverage, however, DACA beneficiaries remain on... 2021
Portia Pedro A PRELUDE TO A CRITICAL RACE THEORETICAL ACCOUNT OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 107 Virginia Law Review Online 143 (June, 2021) In this Essay, I examine the lack of scholarly attention given to the role of civil procedure in racial subordination. I posit that a dearth of critical thought interrogating the connections between procedure and the subjugation of marginalized peoples might be due to the limited experiences of procedural scholars; a misconception that procedural... 2021
Lexie M. Ford A REASONABLE POSSIBILITY OF REFOULEMENT: THE INADEQUACIES OF PROCEDURES TO PROTECT VULNERABLE NONCITIZENS FROM RETURN TO PERSECUTION, TORTURE, OR DEATH 9 Texas A&M Law Review 209 (Fall, 2021) Due primarily to increases in individuals fleeing violence and turmoil in Central America, over 40% of noncitizens arriving in the United States are put on a fast-track removal process and subsequently claim fear of returning to their home countries. A decade ago, the number was only 5%. This influx of asylum-seekers at the border has led to... 2021
Kareem W. Shora A TWENTY-YEAR LESSON: THE ROLE OF CIVIL RIGHTS IN SECURING OUR NATION 12 Journal of National Security Law & Policy 187 (2021) L1-2Introduction: The Failure of Trust and Impact on Communities . L3187 L1A. L2Lesson One: Do Not Conflate Immigration Enforcement with Violence Prevention. L3188 I. Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Provide Collective Security. 189 A. Lesson Two: Avoid the ideological litmus test. 190 B. Lesson Three: Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Should Not Be... 2021
Shalini Bhargava Ray ABDICATION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT 96 Indiana Law Journal 1325 (Summer, 2021) Presidential abdication in immigration law has long been synonymous with the perceived nonenforcement of certain provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act. President Obama's never-implemented policy of deferred action, known as DAPA, serves as the prime example in the literature. But can the President abdicate the duty of faithful execution... 2021
  AFFIRMATIVE DUTIES IN IMMIGRATION DETENTION 134 Harvard Law Review 2486 (May, 2021) Detention has become an undeniably central part of immigration enforcement today. In principle, the constitutional right to be free from deprivation of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law extends to all persons within U.S. territory, regardless of citizenship. In practice, due process for noncitizen detainees tends to be far... 2021
Alexander A. Boni-Saenz AGE DIVERSITY 94 Southern California Law Review 303 (January, 2021) This Article is the first to examine age diversity in the legal literature, mapping out its descriptive, normative, and legal dimensions. Age diversity is a plural concept, as heterogeneity of age can take many forms in various human institutions. Likewise, the normative rationales for these assorted age diversities are rooted in distinct... 2021
Christine Cimini, Doug Smith AN INNOVATIVE APPROACH TO MOVEMENT LAWYERING: AN IMMIGRANT RIGHTS CASE STUDY 35 Georgetown Immigration Law Journal 431 (Winter, 2021) C1-3Table of Contents L1-2Introduction . L3432 I. Literature on Lawyering and Social Change. 442 A. The Critique of Lawyers as Agents for Social Change. 442 B. Newer Models of Social Change Lawyering. 447 II. The Rise and Fall of S-Comm as an Effective Case Study. 454 III. The Immigrant Rights Landscape Prior to S-Comm. 456 A. The Local/National... 2021
Nikolas Bowie ANTIDEMOCRACY 135 Harvard Law Review 160 (November, 2021) Democracy can take root anywhere, from community gardens to the most toxic workplace environments. It's planted whenever people treat one another as political equals, allowing everyone in the community, or demos, to share in exercising power, or kratos. Where democracy is allowed to blossom, it can undermine social hierarchies that have long seemed... 2021
Eduardo R.C. Capulong, Andrew King-Ries, Monte Mills ANTIRACISM, REFLECTION, AND PROFESSIONAL IDENTITY 18 Hastings Race and Poverty Law Journal 3 (Winter, 2021) Intent on more systematically developing the emerging professional identities of law students, the professional identity formation movement is recasting how we think about legal education. Notably, however, the movement overlooks the structural racism imbedded in American law and legal education. While current models of professional... 2021
6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23